So Google finally spilled the beans on Project Snowcrash. It came out into public beta on Wednesday and is called Lively. Reviews have been pretty mixed from what I’ve seen and heard. Most people are simply waiting to see what, if anything, they intend to do with the space.
Perhaps it’s just me, but I’m not really feeling it. There’s no real sense of wonder like I get when stepping into any virtual world or MMOG the first time. While the animations are pretty nifty, and the cartoony style is admittedly appealing, it really appears to be nothing more than a virtual chat-room at this stage. Unlike Second Life, Lively doesn’t leave you much room to do much of anything beyond playing virtual doll-house and chatting. User-created content is not an option, and there’s been no definitive answer on whether or not it’s going to be an option down the road. You can run through the existing content fairly rapidly, and if the room list is any indication, it’s already become a haven for cybersex chats.
That said, it is still Google, and like it or no, that name carries gravitas. Many of the Google products are quite wonderful (I am utterly addicted to Google Calendar myself) and I won’t argue that they’ve got vision. However, they’ve backed some barkers before (hello, Orkut) so while the large portion of their ideas are good solid ones, they’re by no means infallible.

I’ll definitely be keeping my eye on Lively to see how it progresses, as will many who watch the metaverse, I’m sure. Until then, I’ll be keeping my little chunk of metaverse “home” in Second Life, where I can enjoy building (and destroying) things as the mood takes me. For me, user-created content is really a very key part I look for when getting into a virtual world scenario, and in that respect Linden Lab is still pretty much king for the moment.
Of course, Linden Lab also has a long way to go, in terms of stability and losing the user-generated content that you pay for straight out of your inventory, but that’s another post for another time.